The Most Dangerous Man in Football

Chris Borlan
August21/ 2015

You probably read a blurb about Chris Borland when he shocked the NFL earlier this year by abruptly “retiring” from a very promising career as a SF 49er Linebacker and forfeiting millions of $$$$…. while he was “healthy” presumably as any one could be after his football career in high school, college (Wisconsin) and his rookie year with the 49ers.  This rather lengthy article from ESPN Magazine explores his Chris Borlandecision and its mitigating factors.  If the subject of The Dangers Inherent in “Playing Football” interests you, I recommend reading this.

This subject is not one I have gotten on a soap box about, but I have considered it more/more the past few years.   Football HAS INDEED gotten even more dangerous with bigger, stronger, faster players colliding at the college/pro levels.  There are certainly aspects of my Gladiators / Spectators concept intertwined in this issue…. and some introspective quandaries of whether you – as purely a fan of the competition – should “care” how dangerous it might be for those who willingly elect to play the sport at any level.

Yes, it is a companion piece to the Erik Kramer story.

Again… this is a long piece.



Why former 49er Chris Borland is the most dangerous man in football

ONE DAY IN April, the NFL asked Chris Borland to take a random drug test. The timing of this request was, in a word, bizarre, since Borland, a San Francisco 49ers linebacker, had retired a month earlier after a remarkable rookie season. He said he feared getting brain damage if he continued to play.

Borland had been amazed at the reaction to his decision, the implications of which many saw as a direct threat to the NFL. And now here was an email demanding that he pee in a cup before a league proctor within 24 hours or fail the test. “I figured if I said no, people would think I was on drugs,” he said recently. That, he believed, “would ruin my life.” As he thought about how to respond, Borland began to wonder how random this drug test really was.

What did the NFL still want with him? Nobody could have held out much hope that he’d change his mind. On Friday, March 13, when Borland retired via email, he attached a suggested press release, then reaffirmed his intentions in conversations with 49ers officials. Instead of announcing Borland’s retirement, the team sent him a bill — an unsubtle reminder that he’d have to return most of his $617,436 signing bonus if he followed through. That Monday, Borland, knowing he was forgoing at least $2.35 million, not to mention a promising career, made the announcement himself to Outside the Lines. He has since elaborated on the decision to everyone from Face the Nation to Charlie Rose to undergraduates at Wisconsin, where he was an All-American.

Borland has consistently described his retirement as a pre-emptive strike to (hopefully) preserve his mental health. “If there were no possibility of brain damage, I’d still be playing,” he says. But buried deeper in his message are ideas perhaps even more threatening to the NFL and our embattled national sport. It’s not just that Borland won’t play football anymore.

He’s reluctant to even watch it, he now says, so disturbed is he by its inherent violence, the extreme measures that are required to stay on the field at the highest levels and the physical destruction 
he has witnessed to people he loves and admires — especially to their brains.





Leave a Reply

3 Comment threads
4 Thread replies
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
5 Comment authors
BobLeeDougthailandLakepackerTheCowdog Recent comment authors

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

newest oldest most voted
Notify of

I watched rugby (Rugby Rules Football) with a true fan of the sport the other night…..My Aussie friend was as die-hard about his game as the Carolina/State crowd is about their brand of football…..Ruggers play a rough/physical game without pads, but without so-called collision tackles, and certainly have injuries, but not to the scale of American’s brand of football….Other sports like soccer (Association Football 🙂 has an issue with balls in flight (head trauma/long-term brain damage)…..But American football, a game I loved to play has evolved into a modern-day version that is busting out the seams of sanity– it just… Read more »


I have thought that there were two possible solutions. One is to enforce a playing weight like we used to have in junior football. The other is to give the players less padding below. If they have less padding they will be less likely to play in a violent manner. I have felt that as players get bigger and faster that it becomes a question of when and not if.


You were a trainer on the sidelines, you saw firsthand what we looked, and acted like after a REAL bellringer.

I truly love the game, yet I look back, and wonder how the h#ll I ever played it.

As you know, BL, my right shoulder resembles that of an Auschwitz survivor
due to nerve damage, commonly attributed to “football neck.”

Still, nitwit that I am, I’d probably do it all again. That’s what made Borland’s choice so remarkable…and wise…for him.